To hear or not to hear? - results

Here is how other Science Buzz visitors are answering these questions.
Your responses are included.

cochlear implants and an ear

Gail and Bill have a six-year-old son, Bobby. Bobby was born deaf, as was Bill. The entire family uses sign language fluently. Doctors tell the family that a new operation can give Bobby some hearing. Gail and Bill refuse the operation. They believe deafness is not a disability to be "fixed," but rather just a way of being, like being left-handed or being colorblind.

Should doctors be able to force patients to accept treatment against their wishes?


Yes = 36
No = 340
Don't know / No answer = 30
Total votes = 406

What if Gail and Bill object to all types of surgery for religious reasons?
Should doctors be able to force them to accept the treatment?


Yes = 74
No = 286
Don't know / No answer = 46
Total votes = 406

What if one parent wants the operation for Bobby, but the other doesn't?
Should doctors proceed with the operation?


Yes = 106
No = 183
Don't know / No answer = 117
Total votes = 406

What if Bobby wants the operation, but his parents don't?
Should doctors proceed with the operation?


Yes = 219
No = 128
Don't know / No answer = 63
Total votes = 410