What a circus: Should animals be part of the show?

by Thor on Sep. 21st, 2007
in
48

The last stand?: Elephants and their riders strike a pose at the Ringling Brothers Barnum and Bailey Circus at the Alamodome in San Antonio, Texas, recently. Some cities, like Minneapolis, are considering banning wild animals from circus performances (Flickr photo by Edith Frost)
The last stand?: Elephants and their riders strike a pose at the Ringling Brothers Barnum and Bailey Circus at the Alamodome in San Antonio, Texas, recently. Some cities, like Minneapolis, are considering banning wild animals from circus performances (Flickr photo by Edith Frost)

The debate at Minneapolis City Hall keeps churning on: should wild animals be banned from performances in circuses in the city?

If the proposed ordinance would pass, it would make it illegal for circuses to showcase lions, tiger, elephants or other exotic animals. Sponsors of the proposed ordinance say that animals in the shows are often mistreated.

So far in the U.S., only one city, Albuquerque, N.M., has an animal ban for circuses. And in action at the Minneapolis City Council on Thursday, Sept. 20, council members weren’t ready to go to an all-out ban, but passed measures for tighter regulations and fines for animal mistreatment.

So what do you think? Should wild animals be freed from circus performance? Or do they have a great life of easy food, great travel and fun companionship. Personally, I think I’d prefer to be a circus animal than an animal in a zoo. Would you be more or less inclined to go to a circus if it didn’t have wild animals? Share your thoughts here with other Science Buzz readers.

3
Average: 3 (1 vote)

Your Comments, Thoughts, Questions, Ideas

Shannon says:

Definitely keep animals OUT OF THE CIRCUS! Wild animals do not belong in hot, non-ventilated boxcars, or chained 23 hours a day, beaten with bullhooks until they bleed, or caged in quarters so small they can barely turn around. It's pitiful and I have documented the result of those bullhook "guides" (what a joke) on tape, not to mention the hundreds of others as well.

They were just here in Dallas and even one of the security people witnessed a beating during the day when there was no show. They cover up the abcesses and boils with Wonder Dust, a grey powder that blends in with their skin. I caught one on tape they forgot to cover inside the thigh of one of the elehants, and numerous lumps and bumps that were covered on every single elephant. The tool of torture, the "extention of the trainer's arm" they claim (my arm doesn't have a hook at the end, does yours?) is a standard across the board practice to keep elephants terrified and submissive. Electric prods are also used with them, but they don't leave wounds. Their lives are miserable. Only 23 of the elephants Ringling uses were born in captivity (their "conservation" program); the rest were captured from the wild and torn from their families. I cannot imagine a more cruel life. Plus, many of the elephants have a human strain of TB, totally antibiotic resistant, that endangers anyone who comes into close contact with them, like children riding them, workers (one of them died as a result of it already) and the people at the "preshow". There are more sophisticated ways to be entertained than watching wild animals be reduced to cowering creatures performing stupid and demeaning "tricks".

posted on Sat, 09/22/2007 - 10:09am
somebody says:

idk what im doing here right now im bored, but I think that animals should be taken out of circuses

posted on Tue, 03/11/2008 - 5:38pm
kara says:

Animals are very badly hurt at circuses and it is very nasty to see how badly treated they are at backstage. Tigers are chained up in small cages and i love tigers i nearly had the urge of letting them out but it would be to dangerous. I think shannon is right about the poor elephants i saw a bad bruse and a cut on his back it was also bleeding and i think that was the place where they whipped the poor creature i mean it is wrong, for animals to perform in circuses and it SHOULD BE BANNED it isnt nice and can be harmful to the very endangered animals such as tigers and even elephants. a tiger had just had a baby in a cage at the circus and the mother was taken away from her cub and was made to perform with week legs and got whipped three times it was absolutely petrifying i was gob smacked i couldn't believe it when her little cub was then brought on stage to perform tricks it was so nasty i cried i wanted to hit the bloke who trained them but i couldn't they were barred off.

posted on Sat, 04/05/2008 - 10:32am
Shannon says:

If you want to see the cold, hard truth and witness it for you own eyes, visist circuses.com.

posted on Sat, 09/22/2007 - 10:10am
They are more entertaining in the Wild says:

I do not think it's right to use animals in the circus. What we require of them, what they must give up, is simply too much. It is inherently cruel, even without the beatings, bullhooks, electric prods, disease, and other stresses. When I was young, my parents took me to the circus. I watch human circus performers do amazing things, and I enjoy these elaborate, cruelty-free, and awe-inspiring performances every chance I get. These shows are so much more entertaining anyway! Seeing an elephant stand on a ramp does not compare to watching people do gravity-defying stunts or feats of amazing strength, and in beautiful costumes and makeup. I do not believe people need to see an elephant stand on a ramp anymore when they can see elephants on Planet Earth doing far more fantastic things. Maybe Ringling needs the animals because the humans lack any talent.

posted on Sun, 09/23/2007 - 6:26pm
Anonymous says:

How can people be so cruel to animals It makes me sick to think how cruel people really can be to animals .How would they like it to be whipped and hit if they didnt perform properly .Im so glad it is banned because it was discusting and inhumane .

posted on Thu, 10/18/2007 - 10:03am
jayden says:

what do the animals get out of performing nothing they just get wipet and hunt they should be let free. :(

posted on Tue, 10/28/2008 - 7:55pm
Kristal says:

im doing a debate on circus are not a place for animals and im on he neg. team
i have found out alot of things about how they rnt a place for animals but circus are slowly reducing the amount of animals they use for their shows.
and their are alot of other reasons why they should keep going
i belive that some should be banned and others keep going
but you cant just go and say ALL should be banned.

posted on Mon, 10/22/2007 - 4:44am
Anonymous says:

I think that animals shouldn't be in the circus period. its just wrong would any of you want to be locked up in cages and beat with ropes with hooks at the end ITS JUST COMPLETELY WRONG!!!!!!!!!!!!!

posted on Fri, 02/08/2008 - 9:51pm
Peyton says:

Circus animals should be BANNED!!!!!

posted on Mon, 10/29/2007 - 12:29pm
Anonymous says:

Gina says,

just because you 'think' youv seen a miss treated animal duznt mean it happens all the time to all animals in all the circus' a bullhook??? wot the hell?? iv never even hurd of onen iv been involved in ciruses all my life! you people need facts! id rather see animals in the circus than in the zoo!! and how many of you will actualy Go to a circus if it had no animals? and ok some of you say you have proof well prove it! because as i said before maby you have seen animals miss treated, ok well what can i say? all i know is if youv seen it ones it duznt mean youv seen it all.
!!!!!!!!!!!!KEEP ANIMALS IN THE CIRCUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!

posted on Sun, 11/25/2007 - 4:18am
G says:

The proof is in the pudding Gina. Videos upon videos of countless acts of cruelty to animals. Do your homework. You've seen a circus, but obviously you haven't seen what goes on behind the scenes. By the way, have you ever heard of Cirque Du Soliel. The most popular circus in the world? They don't use animals. Isn't it funny how you say how many people would go to the circus if it didn't have animals, when the question should be, how many people DON'T go to the circus because it uses animals? YOU are clearly the one without the facts. I'm sorry to say, but your completely misinformed. By the way...You might want to edit future postings for grammar and punctuation. Respectfully, please keep an open mind, and check out circuses.com. Thank you

posted on Mon, 03/24/2008 - 1:18pm
Anonymous says:

I don't think animals should be part of circuses. Most circus animals are endangered species and deserve a better home.

posted on Mon, 11/26/2007 - 2:13pm
Anonymous says:

i think its true they shoul be banned it is so cruel some one must have a lot of nerve to hurt an animal if someone is killed it is there own FAULT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! along with that they test stuff animals like putting BLEACH in there EYES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
selfish cowards!!

posted on Tue, 11/27/2007 - 2:13pm
Anonymous says:

yah, its like, really mean to be practicly torchering animals. Animals should be out in the wild where they belong. not in circuses where they could get hurt.

posted on Thu, 12/06/2007 - 10:47am
hey there says:

I aggree with u. animals are people to. how wolud u like to be caged? I hope not!!!!!!!!! circuses

posted on Thu, 11/29/2007 - 11:30am
Haley Wilson says:

animals deserve better

posted on Fri, 11/30/2007 - 10:44am
Anonymous says:

I think you are right they are so cruel to the animals
THAT IS IT I AM GOING TO EMAIL THE GOVERMENT

posted on Wed, 10/29/2008 - 2:01am
Anonymous says:

I LOVE THE CIRCUS AND ALLL THE ANIMALs

posted on Thu, 11/29/2007 - 2:16pm
amber says:

i dont think animas should be put in circuses either. i feel really bad. someone commment me bak !

posted on Wed, 12/05/2007 - 12:54pm
BREEANNA says:

I agree 100% with you its just wrong animal cruelty comment me back!!!

posted on Fri, 02/08/2008 - 9:57pm
Mikayla says:

I think animals should left alone. they should be able to run free.

posted on Fri, 11/30/2007 - 1:30pm
Abigail says:

I think that animals should be left alone in there natural habitat. It's just rong to take them out of there home. I mean, how would you feal if someone took you out of your home? I would feal realy, realy sad! I'm just saying that you should leave the animals ALONE! I mean it!

posted on Fri, 11/30/2007 - 1:37pm
leo hyde says:

free the animals man

posted on Wed, 12/05/2007 - 1:45pm
Anonymous says:

I will never take my kids to the circus. I know elephants were not made to stand on their heads. There is nothing natural nor cute about it, it simply looks ridiculous

posted on Wed, 01/09/2008 - 12:31pm
Anonymous says:

IM WITH YA

posted on Tue, 02/12/2008 - 11:22pm
Anonymous says:

I don't go to the circus now because of the animal cruelty I believe is happening. I would Definitely take the kids if there were NO animals.

posted on Wed, 01/09/2008 - 12:33pm
Rhii says:

i got homework for animals in circus. i gotta have against and for? but i cant find anything. could people comment back on this thanks. Rhii x

posted on Wed, 01/09/2008 - 1:56pm
ruby says:

no they sould not u r so crul and selfish!!!
u have a life let them. i dont no how u could it is so crul i can see you dont care thow
becouse u r 2 selfish and i would take my 8 children if ther was no animals

posted on Mon, 01/14/2008 - 12:33pm
Anonymous says:

Heyy
I think they SHOULD NOT use animals for their shows....i thinkthey should be able to run free rather than chained for 23 hours or so....its soo sad!!!!

posted on Sun, 01/27/2008 - 11:06am
JO says:

Man HAS THE ABILITY TO JUSTIFY HIS CRUELTY AT ALL TIMES AND ANIMALS IN CIRCUSES AND LABORATORIES IS JUST ONE EXAMPLE. HOWEVER, DO NOT THINK THAT JUST BECAUSE WE ARE A "WESTERN" CIVILIZATION WE ARE THE ONLY ONES WHO DO THIS. JUST CHECK OUT HOW ELEPHANTS ARE "'TRAINED "
IN SUCH PLACES AS BALI AND THAILAND. SEEMS WE ALL BELIEVE THAT ANIMALS HAVE A RIGHT TO EXIST AS LONG AS THEY SERVE SOME FUNCTION FOR HUMANS.
NO MORE ANIMAL ACTS OR ZOO PRISONS, ONLY LARGE ANIMAL SANCTUARIES AT MOST.

posted on Sun, 02/03/2008 - 7:49pm
Alice In Wonderland says:

I personaly love the cirus but i dont think it is ok for wild animals like the elehanpts to be in the circus because it is just bad they should be roaming the outback.. Yeahh i said thats righttt PEACE :]

posted on Sat, 02/09/2008 - 11:13am
Anonymous says:

i think its great tht we can see all these wonderful creatures from all around the work and that we all can enjoy all of Gods creatures. yes they are not in there natural habatate but many zoo's are getting much better at how they keep there animals and are getting colser and colser to a more natural habitate for them

posted on Sat, 02/09/2008 - 12:30pm
YSC Employee says:

Animal cruelty has been happening more and more worldwide. I believe that circuses should NOT be using animals to entertain audiences like that. Taking them out of their natural habitats to perform shows which they were not made to do is just plain wrong. Come on people, it's ethics. Training these animals to do these performances is just like concentration camps. Forcing people to do labor which they shouldn't HAVE to do. Think about it. And you may say, the difference with this example is that we're HUMANS and their asking about ANIMALS. All around, its the same things. Maybe they're not entitled to Human Rights, but circuses are and can definitely be amazing without the animal cruelty.

posted on Sat, 02/09/2008 - 5:24pm
Christina says:

I think it is interesting how when it is cute animals, it is horrible, but if it is ugly animals, who cares! For example, the foods we eat, chicken, pigs, cow all live life in horrible conditions, being raised just to get fat so we can eat them... Iowa is known for it's pork industries, but have you ever driven through Iowa and see pigs out? Never, but you can smell them and see bigggg metal buildings were they live. Sad.

posted on Sun, 02/10/2008 - 1:38pm
Shannon .M. says:

I don't think that animals should be allowed circuses. I am doing a dabate at school about animals in circuses and I am on the Negative side. So I am against it!

Most of us see animals in the ring uncaged, unchained, maybe wearing a colourful costume with bright lights and music. But, we don't see them the other 23 hours or so a day when they are chained in darkness, denied the sunshine, proper food and freedom. Most circus animals are brutalised by their trainers Circuses are no life for wild animals like elephants, giraffes, tigers and lions. When they are not performing in the ring, most of these animals are imprisoned in small cages with no space for exercise.

There are also serious doubts about the training methods used. Many welfare campaigners believe that trainers can only teach animals to perform silly, degrading tricks by punishing them until they are too frightened to refuse.

The smaller the circus, the more despicable the conditions and unreliable the care given to the animals. The cruelty is mostly hidden. So is the animals' suffering. Circus promoters will vehemently deny any accusations of cruelty - the business would fold if the truth were admitted.

Animals in circuses lack any real legal protection. In the UK it is legal to use as much violent force as is deemed 'necessary' to make an animal obey, perform, learn a trick, or move. As long as the person stops beating the animal once it complies, it is legal. There are no legally enforceable standards for the welfare and care of circus animals. Consequently, the living conditions and safety standards of circuses are appalling.
all in the name of entertainment.

posted on Wed, 03/12/2008 - 6:30pm
Anonymous says:

If animals do really get hurt in the circus i think there should be a ban for animals in circuses.

posted on Sun, 04/13/2008 - 8:55pm
Cassy says:

I believe that animals should not perform in the circus because it is cruel and unnatural. They are kept in small, enclosed cages where they barely have enough room to breath.... It's just so cruel!

posted on Fri, 04/18/2008 - 8:59am
jackson says:

i think circus animals should be banned it is cruel and they are not raised by thereown parants and its horrible to see poor animals being hurt like that. The sad thing is circus animals live and sleep in small cages.

posted on Wed, 06/18/2008 - 6:31am
Anonymous says:

I totally agree with you jackson. In circuses animals are abused and whipped and stuff. And they use cruel devices to teach animals tricks. Die circuses!

posted on Wed, 06/18/2008 - 8:55am
OMG says:

OMG!!!! Those ELEPHANT are so CUUUUUUUUUTTTTTTTTEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ^ . ^

posted on Wed, 06/18/2008 - 11:48am
Circus Hater!!!!! says:

I think it is absolutley horrible that they do this to animals I think they should be sued and should set the animals free! What horrible people I've been behind the scenes of the circus and it is HORRIBLE!!!!!!!!!! I hate the circus with all my might and I think they are heartless people who should think about how they would feel if put in the animals position!!!!! I strongly think the circus should set the anmilas free they have PLENTY of other ats to entertain their audiences!

posted on Wed, 07/23/2008 - 11:23am
Annette says:

i just watched some horrific videos of wild animals be beaten, wiped, verbally abused into doing, what these trianers want them to do. I've see the blood run on the concrete. The animals screaming in pain. Stand outside at the circus & fairs on short leaches shaking they're heads back and forth for hours. I cried, I cried so hard I had to stop watching for an hour. Then I researched this site. I need to know that these animal trainers are being punished for what they are doing. And if this is the only way, to train. Then it has to be stopped.
We wonder why animal in circuses attack, it because hey just can't take it anymore. And then they're shot...and put on the news as animals gone crazy...
What would you do if you knew these terrible things were going on. I think these people are cruel and alittle crazy to be able to do these horrific things to these animals. Lets clean house. Lets stop animal abuse...where ever it is, for the animals. Please, it just wrong.

posted on Tue, 08/05/2008 - 11:12pm
Anonymous says:

I don't see how it's not obvious to everyone, that wild animals that are forced to "perform" for human amusement are miserable. Millions of years of evolution honed these creatures for survival in a natural environment. Circuses are a selfish, twisted form of human entertainment and are an abomination to the natural earth.

posted on Tue, 10/14/2008 - 11:15pm
Ryan hehir says:

Why do you do this it is just cruel. Its not like they get payed you just think it is ok to smash them with sticks. How would you like it if you were cramped in small cages and smashed with iron poles!

PLEASE THINK ABOU WHAT YOU ARE DOING!!!!!!!!!!

Ryan hehir

posted on Tue, 10/28/2008 - 8:04pm
Anonymous says:

ok people wild animals should NOT be kept in a circus but some of the animals in circus have been born in the circus and its all they no and are used to it. so it all depents on how they got there.

posted on Tue, 11/25/2008 - 10:36am
Anonymous says:

Unfortunately legal safeguards are not in place to protect animals in circuses. Although circuses and traveling shows must comply with the federal Animal Welfare Act (AWA), the regulations are not specific or adequately enforced. Every major circus that uses animals has been cited for violating the minimal standards of care set forth in the Animal Welfare Act. Officials from the U.S. Department of Agriculture (which enforces the AWA) have repeatedly ignored obvious physical trauma to animals, eyewitness accounts of mistreatment, and sworn testimony from former circus employees who report mistreatment of elephants. In fact, the AWA does not prohibit the use of bullhooks.

Watching wild animals perform unnatural tricks does not teach our children respect or appreciation for animals. Circuses teach children that it's acceptable to exploit and mistreat animals for amusement.

Keep animals in the wild.

posted on Sun, 11/30/2008 - 11:11pm
emma says:

i think animals should be part of the circus becuase, the people that buy the tickects dont just wanna see clowns and stuff. They wanna see tigers,horses,lions,elephants etc doing tricks for there entertainment, and the animals get praise things like food or a pat or something so they know that they did good.
But i also think they shouldn't be in it because these animals are starved or beaten if they don't perform the trick right or act iresponsibiltlly on the night of the show or in the cage.

So im tied in this vote.

posted on Mon, 12/01/2008 - 12:37am

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <h3> <h4> <em> <i> <strong> <b> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <blockquote> <object> <embed> <param>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Images can be added to this post.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options